Live · 22 Oct 2026 SPX 7,640.20 -1.51% NDX 28,889.97 -3.13% VIX 19.94 +19.54% GOLD 4,048.10 -2.46% CL 99.48 -2.27% BTC 81,293.02 -3.24%
NAS100 28,890 −3.13% S&P 7,640 −1.51% GOLD $4,048 −2.46% BTC $81,293 −3.24% VIX 19.94 +19.54% live tape · as of 19:01 UTC
Vol. II · No. 295Thursday, 22 October 2026
TTitan Protect
Case Studies · Earnings Echo

IBM Compounds at 34% ROE. Here’s the Receipt.

Filed Wednesday 21 October 2026 · 12:54 UTC · Entry no. 131141 · scored against the close · never edited

IBM Compounds at 34% ROE. Here’s the Receipt.
Earnings Preview · 21 October 2026
Where our screen stands going in
Fails the principled screen, Debt ratio. A strong business is not the same as a suitable one; for a values-conscious book this is a do-not-chase regardless of the print.
What the Street expects
Consensus looks for earnings of about $2.87 a share on revenue near $16.8B. Over the next twelve months analysts pencil in $13.15 of earnings per share against $11.11 over the last twelve, growth of about 18%. The median analyst target is $240 (range $174 to $297), 0% below the $240.96 share price, across 23 analysts.
How it has traded on past prints
Across the last 25 reports, the shares moved an average of +0.5% in the five sessions after the print and -0.6% over twenty. After a beat the average follow-through was -2.5%; after a miss, +15.2%. Misses have not been punished more than beats were rewarded, so the headline number alone has been a poor guide to the reaction here; guidance and the call matter more. There is no reliable drift pattern: the first move has often faded, so chasing the gap has not paid.
Levels that matter
At $240.96 the shares sit 28% below the 52-week high of $332.46 and 21% above the low of $199.19 (31% of the way up the range). The 50-day average is $232.00, below the price. The 200-day average is $253.49, above the price.
Valuation going in
The shares trade close to our fair-value estimate (+6% margin of safety): fairly priced, little cushion for a miss. Our fair-value estimate is $257.32 against the current share price of $240.96. The shares trade at 21.1 times trailing earnings and 17.8 times forward earnings. Revenue is growing about 1% with net margins near 16%.
Our stance
We are not participants, the name fails our principled screen, so we watch it as a sentiment gauge, not a holding.
What the flow says going in
Underlying money flow reads as distribution (21-day Chaikin Money Flow -0.31, five-day price change +2.2%, as of 2026-10-16, desk flow model).

This is analysis, not financial advice. Always manage your risk.

How This Entry Scores

Every level named in a session brief is scored against the next scheduled close. Nothing is edited after filing: if a level breaks, the record shows it as filed, not as corrected. The desk's full scored history sits on the track record page.

Continue Reading View all Case Studies →
Membership

The ledger is public. The desk behind it is not.

Membership opens every room and every entry the day it is filed, with the same dated honesty the record is built on.

Join the desk

This is analysis, not financial advice. Always manage your risk.

Get our weekly market brief free.