Ethical Finance Series

Ethical Investment Funds.
The Complete Picture.

ESG labels are not a guarantee of ethical compliance. Learn how to look past the marketing language, detect greenwashing, and screen a fund's actual holdings against a rigorous ethical standard.

Screen Any Fund's Holdings

Beyond the label.

The term "ethical fund" is one of the most abused phrases in modern finance. A fund can carry an ESG label while holding significant positions in fossil fuel companies, defence contractors, or conventional banks. This practice—known as greenwashing—is the gap between marketing claims and investment reality.

The UK's Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) introduced Sustainability Disclosure Requirements (SDR) and an anti-greenwashing rule effective May 2024, requiring fund managers to substantiate any sustainability claims. However, the most reliable protection for investors remains direct examination of a fund's underlying holdings.

The Substance Screen: Greenwashing Detection Tests

Test 1: Holdings Transparency

Does the fund publish a full list of its holdings? Any fund that refuses to disclose its portfolio in detail should be treated with extreme caution. Genuine ethical funds welcome scrutiny.

Test 2: Revenue Purity

What percentage of each holding's revenue comes from non-compliant activities? A fund claiming to be "fossil-fuel free" may still hold companies with 10-15% revenue from energy services.

Test 3: Exclusion Consistency

Are the exclusion criteria applied consistently across all holdings? Some funds exclude tobacco producers but hold tobacco distributors. Genuine ethical screening applies the same standard throughout the supply chain.

ESG vs. Shariah Screening: A Comparison

Criteria	ESG Screening	Shariah Screening
Primary Framework	Environmental, Social, Governance scores	AAOIFI / AAOIFI-derived standards
Debt Ratio Test	Not typically applied	Total debt < 33% of total assets
Interest Income	Not typically excluded	Non-compliant income < 5% of total revenue
Alcohol / Gambling	Optional / variable	Mandatory exclusion
Conventional Banking	Often included	Excluded (interest-based)
Independent Oversight	Third-party ESG raters (inconsistent)	Independent Shariah board

Frequently Asked Questions

What does ESG actually stand for?

ESG stands for Environmental, Social, and Governance. It is a framework used to assess a company's non-financial performance. Environmental factors include carbon emissions and resource usage; Social factors include labour practices and community impact; Governance factors include board structure and executive pay.

Can an ESG fund also be Shariah-compliant?

Yes. There is significant overlap between ESG and Shariah screening. Both tend to exclude tobacco, gambling, and weapons. However, Shariah screening adds a financial ratio test (debt and interest income limits) that ESG frameworks do not apply, making Shariah screening generally more rigorous.

How can I check if a specific fund is genuinely ethical?

The most reliable method is to obtain the fund's full holdings list and screen each underlying company against a rigorous ethical standard. The Titan Protect ethical screener covers over 13,500 tickers and applies a dual-lens methodology combining intrinsic value analysis with AAOIFI-standard compliance checks.

Informed decisions. Not marketing.

Screen any fund's holdings against our 13,571-ticker ethical database. Identify non-compliant positions before you invest.

Explore the Screener

Explore More

Ethical Hub Screener (13,571 tickers) Zakat Calculator Purification Calculator Mortgage Comparison Track Record Glossary Insider Intelligence

Ethical Investment Funds. The Complete Picture.